Sara (Briana Banks) and John (Mark Davis) are two very good friends. They've spent numerous nights consoling each other when one of them was heart broken or simply disappointed with life. One night, as Sara experienced another heartbreak, John came to her rescue and tried, as always, to cheer her up. They then exchanged stories about former loves and lost hopes, from the man she thought was exclusive, the girl he thought loved him with the same fire with which he had loved her, from the girl she stole from him, to her friend she slept with ... As the night goes on and the past is slowly dredged up, they discover that the love they were respectively seeking might just be right under their noses!